Reporter's Notebook

Track of the Day
Show Newer Notes

The latest contributor to our series recommends a song to get your New Year’s resolution on its feet:

I don’t know how weird this is, but one of my favs for workouts is Muse’s “Knights of Cydonia.” It’s got a great beat and a relentless momentum that just builds and builds and keeps me moving.

Update from another reader:

In my humble opinion, no mention of Knights is complete without a link to Muse’s amazing performance at Wembley in 2007.

A reader responds to Adrienne’s bleg with some German electronic:

“Exterminate, Annihilate, Destroy” by Rotersand is probably the weirdest song on my running playlist. It’s damn effective, because it has the pace of a march sped up for the purposes of being an EBM [electronic body music] track. It also samples Dr. Who for the duration. So it’s an EBM Dalek march, but it’s wonderful.

More recommendations from readers here and here. Send yours to [email protected].

A reader joins this one:

M83’s “Oblivion” is my weirdest, greatest pick for your running playlist. It’s from a science fiction movie of the same name that didn’t do very well critically or at the box office, but the track makes up for all of that. There’s M83 creating these immense walls of sound while Susanne Sundfør’s vocals crash against massive drums and a swelling orchestral accompaniment. As it ends, it suddenly vanishes into a tranquil piano outro.

A reader starts off our series of the “weirdest, greatest” songs to run to:

I start my run to “O… Saya” from the Slumdog Millionaire soundtrack (A R Rahman feat. MIA). It starts slowly, not unlike my body at the beginning of a run. It builds intensity with Taiko drums, which reminds my legs that yes, running is a thing they do. The guitar starts, legs slightly warm, head up—yep, I can do this.  By the time MIA starts singing about running, speed, and ninjas, I feel like I too could conquer Who Wants to Be A Millionaire—or at least feel smarter than the Fox News talking head on the screen on my treadmill (it’s there by default; I’m just too lazy to change the channel).

Have a running track to recommend for our New Year’s list? Drop us an email.

From a reader on the Christian Sabbath:

Your mentions of Thundercat reminded me of some music I’ve been blown away by this year. A tiny bit of context. I grew up in a midwestern Christian family, listening to dc Talk in the early ‘90s and thinking they were cool—before realizing they weren’t and then spending years cringing at the mention of “Christian hip-hop.” But this year, after resisting fiercely, I was shocked to learn that there actually is (for the first time) excellent music coming out in that genre. Two albums I want to mention:

When you said Thundercat, I thought of this record by KB—another one of Kendrick’s bassists appears on it. Check out tracks 1, 2, 3, 6 and 13 [embedded above]. Today I listened all the way through this record by J.Givens for at least the 20th time.  From a lyrical standpoint it’s on par with what Lin-Manuel Miranda did with Hamilton, and in terms of production and album construction I put it on the same shelf as My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy. (It opens a little abruptly, but push through and by the second track it hooks you and the rest of the way through it’s a ride.)

Both of these artists wear their Christianity on their sleeve in every song, so they’re never going to get the play Kendrick does. But their music is phenomenal, and I think there are a lot of people who secretly yearn to see Christian hip-hop, as a genre, redeemed.

Have a track to recommend for the feature? Drop us an email. The archive is here.

A reader recommends one for the day:

I’m really enjoying the Christmas songs series and wanted to point you to John Gorka’s sublime take on “I Heard the Bells on Christmas Day.” It, more than any version, I think, truly captures the power and feeling of the lyrics.

The song was originally a poem written by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, a co-founder of The Atlantic and contributor. Here’s some backstory on the poem:

During the American Civil War, Longfellow’s oldest son Charles Appleton Longfellow joined the Union cause as a soldier without his father’s blessing. Longfellow was informed by a letter dated March 14, 1863, after Charles had left. “I have tried hard to resist the temptation of going without your leave but I cannot any longer,” he wrote. “I feel it to be my first duty to do what I can for my country and I would willingly lay down my life for it if it would be of any good.”

Charles soon got an appointment as a lieutenant but, in November, he was severely wounded in the Battle of New Hope Church (in Virginia) during the Mine Run Campaign. Coupled with the recent loss of his wife Frances, who died as a result of an accidental fire, Longfellow was inspired to write “Christmas Bells.” He first wrote the poem on Christmas Day in 1863.

Every year for years, I’ve dreaded the arrival of Christmas music. How many times can you hear “God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen” in one month? One of the few exceptions was that WAPS, a local radio station in Akron, would always play the Kinks’ “Father Christmas.” Forget all the gushy mumbo-jumbo and crass commercialism—as befits the Kinks, it’s irreverent, witty, pissed-off Christmas music. Here’s the chorus:

Father Christmas, give us some money
Don’t mess around with those silly toys.
We’ll beat you up if you don’t hand it over
We want your bread so don’t make us annoyed
Give all the toys to the little rich boys

It’s a funny punch line, but I’ve always found this verse to be rather poignant:

But give my daddy a job ‘cause he needs one
He’s got lots of mouths to feed
But if you’ve got one, I’ll have a machine gun
So I can scare all the kids down the street

Economists have found that giving people cash is the most effective way of providing welfare to the poor.

A reader pivots off our year-end list:

Instead of listing my favorite song/album of the year, I thought I’d mention my favorite music video. Donnie Trumpet and the Social Experiment’s "Sunday Candy" is a joyous mini-musical with scene and costume changes, wonderful dancing and a “let’s put on a show” energy. Filmed in one continuous take, the rapping is by Chance the Rapper and the gospel inflected chorus is sung by Jamila Woods. It makes me smile every time I watch it and, really, what else do you need?

Working from Sophie’s great idea, we’ve been working through a sort of double-canon of Christmas music the last couple weeks—songs both secular and holy. But where there’s a canon, there must also be an anti-canon. And for me, the greatest song in the Christmas anti-canon will always be Big Star’s “Jesus Christ.”

“Jesus Christ” comes comes from the great, underappreciated power-pop group’s shambling, incoherent, brilliant third record, (creatively titled) Third. It’s hard to say that anything really belongs on the album, but “Jesus Christ” sticks out in particular:

Why is there a Christmas song in the middle of a non-Christmas album? What does it mean? The track begins, for no clear, reason with the goofy tune “Mañana,” then grinds to a halt and pivots into the main song, announced by a jangly guitar riff and Jody Stephens’ thunderous drums. The lyrics are a strange mash-up of hymns (“Angels from the realms of glory/Stars shone bright above/Royal David's city/Was bathed in the light of love”) with a straightforward chorus: “Jesus Christ was born today, Jesus Christ was born.”

Was singer and songwriter Alex Chilton serious? Unlike his erstwhile bandmate Chris Bell, Chilton doesn’t seem to have been particularly religious. The rest of the record is full of other oddities: the tear-jerkingly earnest “Blue Moon”; “Thank You Friends,” almost Dylanesque in its spite; and misleading covers of “Nature Boy” and “Whole Lotta Shaking.” Chilton does a wry parody of a bandleader introducing the sax solo—“Now we’re gonna get born”—a suggestion of a sneer. But there’s so much sarcasm and so much aching sincerity across Big Star’s catalog that you have no idea whether to take a line like “And the wrong shall fail, and the right prevail” as mockery of Christian piety or a tribute to genuine faith.

I think that ambiguity makes the song—which, as Stewart Mason notes, has become a college-rock December staple. As both a wiseass and a believer, I like to listen to it all year, but it takes on particular meaning around Christmas.

Tis the season to drown in holiday music (check out our “12 Days of Christmas Songs” series), but legends must be paid respect. And the one true and pure Christmas carol is, of course, “Fa La La” by Justin Bieber featuring Boys II Men. This song is sacred and does not need defending, but for the non-believers:

  1. What is more strange and passionate than an adolescent and three grown men singing to their unnamed love? About their soft desire to listen to her chest? Mixing tenderness, the holiday spirit, a bop of a staccato hook, and some very dope arm and upper-body improv in the video? This is the reason for the season.
  1. The music video is also a work of art. Look at young Bieber widen his eyes at the 0:29 mark, right after singing “when you open your eeeeyes.” Symbolism. Brilliance. Then Shawn Stockman’s very extra, very necessary run at the end, with his finger in the air running alongside, like a lifeline for his vocal cords. And shoutout to a legend, the subtle reference to Yung Joc’s glory era at the 2:05 mark.
  1. There is nothing holier than these lyrics: “Baby I hear melodies when your heart beats/Baby it sings to me like/Fa la la la la, fa la la la la/I know that it's Christmas time.” Who has sung of a heart marking the passage of time? What can be more divine? Boys II Men and Jus are (basically) singing: “Your heart is a jingle bell, your love is hallowed ground.”

In case you missed it, the staff put together three dozen of their favorite tracks from 2015. I especially dig David’s pick here:

This superb R&B track isn’t a cover of the Buddy Miles classic, though there’s a family resemblance—a locomotive funk, an infectious hook. But where Miles is ragged and rocked up, Thundercat’s is slinky, slow burning, restrained, wounded, and harmonically richer. The singer and bassist—he plays a six-string instrument, which he strums and plucks like a guitar, slaps and pops like Larry Graham, or uses to lay down a groove like Jaco Pastorius—is a collaborator of Kendrick Lamar and Kamasi Washington. When did jazz fusion get cool again?

Any song that definitely should have made the list? Drop us an email to make your case.

More Notes From The Atlantic
  • Notes Home