freeissn picture
u_topn picture
Atlantic Unbound Sidebar

Return to the March 1999 A&E Preview Cover


Everyone's a Critic
Who do you think should win this year's Academy Awards? Discuss Ella's picks and share your own in a special film conference in Post & Riposte.

Arts & Entertainment Preview - March 1999

Film
B Y   E L L A   T A Y L O R

The 1998 Ella Awards


    The Butcher Boy

With few exceptions, the critics and the moviegoing public went their separate ways in 1998. Here, then, are my picks of the year, some of which came and went so fast you may have to catch them on video.

Best Picture: With ebullient flair and a sensibility at once playful, savage, and sympathetic, Neil Jordan's extraordinary -- and extraordinarily overlooked -- The Butcher Boy humanizes the growing pains and pleasures of an out-of-control lad growing up in post-Second-World War Ireland.
Runners-up: The butcher boy grows up in The General, John Boorman's black-and-white beauty about Irish gangster Martin Cahill; Steven Spielberg and Terrence Malick measure the costs of war in Saving Private Ryan and The Thin Red Line; Warren Beatty raps his way to liberation in Bulworth; Paul Schrader adapts Russell Banks with tact and sensitivity in Affliction.

Best Foreign-Language Picture: Ecstatic, brutal, weird, and gorgeous, Japanese director Takeshi Kitano's Fireworks explores the strange mind of a detective who brings equal zest and method to taking out mobsters and caring for his terminally ill wife.
Runners-up: Danish director Thomas Vinterberg takes a hand-held camera to a riotously dysfunctional family in The Celebration; Bruno Dumont gets inside the head of a young French racist in The Life of Jesus; in Abbas Kiarostami's Taste of Cherry a man drives across Iran to find an accomplice in his own suicide.

    The Truman Show's
    Laura Linney

Best Documentary: Jonathan Stack and Liz Garbus's The Farm, an urgent, heartfelt examination of life in a Louisiana penitentiary.
Runners-up: Bennett Miller's whimsical The Cruise, a one-man study of a logorrheic Manhattan street poet; Danielle Gardner's lively, touching Soul in the Hole, about inner-city basketball players; Dariusz Jablonski's The Photographer, a reconstruction of daily life in the Lodz ghetto during the Second World War, using photographs taken by the ghetto's Nazi accountant.

Best Actress: Emily Watson and Rachel Griffiths, for their symbiotic passion as the cellist Jacqueline Du Pré and her less-gifted sister in Hilary and Jackie.
Runners-Up: Cate Blanchett, as the mercurial, politically savvy monarch in Elizabeth; Dominique Swain, for her grown-up turn as precocious child-woman in Lolita; Meryl Streep, as the prissy eldest sister of an Irish matriarchy in Dancing at Lughnasa.

Best Actor: Brendan Gleeson, for the elastic range of his performance as the charismatic Irish gangster in The General.
Runners-up: Ian McKellen, wry, anguished, and lyrical as the gay film director James Whale in Gods and Monsters; John Hurt, likewise as the gay writer in Love and Death on Long Island; Nick Nolte, full of bluster and pain as the self-destructive cop in Affliction; Denis Leary, as the Boston-Irish thug in Monument Ave.

Rushmore's Murray  

Best Supporting Actress: Laura Linney, for her hilariously over-the-top Nurse Ratched takeoff as Jim Carrey's wife in The Truman Show.
Runners-up: Kathy Bates, for her funny, affecting turn in the Betsey Wright/Vince Foster role in Primary Colors; Joan Allen, as the '50s mother who serves cholesterol breakfasts from hell in Pleasantville; Lisa Kudrow, for her acidic delivery as the ultimately endearing spinster in The Opposite of Sex; Kimberly Elise, for her quiet dignity as Oprah Winfrey's surviving daughter in Beloved.

Best Supporting Actor: Bill Murray, for his hangdog gravity and wild unreason, as the tycoon defeated by life in Wes Anderson's Rushmore.
Runners-up: Billy Bob Thornton, as a simpleton who belatedly grows a conscience in A Simple Plan; Jon Voight, for his restrained grace as a dogged detective in The General; Philip Seymour Hoffman, as the nerdy crank caller in Happiness; Chris Eigeman, as the unctuous club manager in The Last Days of Disco.


Grace Notes


    Gods and Monsters

Love: Danny DeVito puts the moves on Holly Hunter in Living Out Loud, fails, but shows her there is a life to be lived outside the resentful voices in her head.

War: In The Thin Red Line an American grunt, after plucking gold teeth from the mouths of dying Japanese soldiers on a battlefield, gets the shakes and throws the teeth away.

Beauty: Brendan Fraser, as a gardener befriended by film director James Whale (Ian McKellen), honors his dead friend at the end of Gods and Monsters by walking the monster walk.

Chastity: Cate Blanchett's Queen puts on a chalky face and retroactively claims her virginity in Elizabeth: "Behold, Lord Burghley, I am married to England."

Ready for her close-up: A très pink poodle in Babe: Pig in the City grieves for her glamorous past. "This recalls the glory days, when I was dizzy with privilege."


Everyone's a Critic: Who do you think should win this year's Academy Awards? Discuss Ella's picks and share your own in a special film conference in Post & Riposte.

Ella Taylor is a film critic for LA Weekly.

Go to ...

Copyright © 1999 by The Atlantic Monthly Company. All rights reserved.
Cover Atlantic Unbound The Atlantic Monthly Post & Riposte Atlantic Store Search